If you’re an office manager, you already carry a ridiculous amount of weight—schedules, systems, insurance, team morale, the works. Add “find and retain a great associate dentist” to the list and it can feel impossible. Yet associate production is a major lever for patient access, profitability, and owner sanity—so getting this hire right matters a lot.

Here’s the tough reality: many sources peg associateship failure around the 12-month mark—roughly three out of four don’t last—making it one of the costliest revolving doors in dentistry. That’s exactly the problem Dentist Partner Pros set out to fix.

The good news? You don’t need perfect candidates. You need a better system. Below is a simple, office-manager-friendly framework—pulled directly from Bryton Nield’s guest appearance on AADOM Radio (Episode 146: How Office Managers Can Hire & Retain Right-fit Associates) and the playbooks we use with private practices every day.

1) Begin with the end in mind (define your associate “avatar”)

Before you post a job, get crystal clear on what “thriving here” looks like. Document:

  • Non-negotiable clinical competencies
  • Behavioral traits and values that match your culture
  • Success milestones at 90/180/365 days

Do this with the owner doctor and key team leads so there’s alignment. When you know who you’re hiring for, sourcing and vetting stop feeling random and rushed.

2) Source where your avatar actually is

Once you know the profile, go where those candidates live:

  • General job boards (Indeed, ZipRecruiter)
  • Dental-specific boards and state dental association sites
  • Warm network taps: ask your team, “Who are the best people you’ve ever worked with?”

Pro tip: Your job post should signal your culture clearly—mentorship, CE support, growth path, schedule norms. The right people self-select in when the copy speaks to them.

3) Replace “panic hires” with a real vetting process

Rushed, one-and-done interviews are a big reason associateships fail. Build a lightweight but intentional sequence:

  1. Screen
  2. Structured interview (behavioral questions)
  3. References + license checks
  4. Onsite/working interview

Behavioral questions beat yes/no every time. Example: “Tell me about a time a treatment plan didn’t go as expected. What did you learn and what did you change afterward?”

4) Don’t overweight the hand skills—protect the culture

Clinical competence is table stakes; culture misalignment is what quietly kills associateships. Balance your scorecard so values and communication carry real weight.

5) Remember: you’re being interviewed, too

Great associates are choosing you as much as you’re choosing them. Sell what makes your practice a place to grow:

  • Mentorship & CE
  • Clear growth path
  • How success is supported

6) Build a pipeline before you “need one”

The pressure to put “someone—anyone” in the chair fuels bad hires. Keep a light-touch pipeline year-round:

  • Quarterly “hello” messages to promising contacts
  • Lunch-and-learns with local residencies
  • Internal “alumni” list of former team members

7) Onboard like retention depends on it (because it does)

Winning the offer isn’t the finish line. Map the first 90–180 days with goals, shadowing, feedback loops, and team integration. Consistency reduces anxiety and accelerates contribution.

Quick checklist

  • Draft your associate avatar
  • Rewrite your job post with culture and success metrics
  • Stand up a 3–4 step vetting flow
  • Build a balanced scorecard
  • Map a 90-day onboarding plan
  • Start an internal pipeline list

The bottom line

Right-fit associates aren’t found by luck or rushed site visits. They’re attracted by clarity, selected through structure, and retained by leadership and onboarding. That’s the system we’ve used to flip the industry’s failure narrative—and it’s a system office managers can run with confidence.

AADOM Radio

Related Articles (for further reading)